Wednesday, March 21, 2018

If we eat American RIce for two years in areas of high incidence of CKDU the disease is reversible - and a MILLION lives will be saved

The world's largest Rice Mill owned by a Farmer Cooperative Riceland - Jonesboro Arkansas

Chronic Kidney Disease of unknown Etiology – CKDU a totally preventable ecological disaster – Kamal Gammanpila, PhD and MPhil, DIC @ the OPA auditorium on Wednesday, 21st March 2018 @ 6pm

What an eye opener of logic from this distinguished scientist – He believes we are wasting resources in tackling the symptoms and not the disease per se, and so we are setting up Sri Lanka for a disaster and at least a Million deaths from Kidney Disease in the next few years, UNLESS his fears are addressed and proper scientific thought is used to eliminate factors, and concentrate on the main factor or factors, upon a process of elimination.

In his opinion, one has to have an engineering mind, as well as a medical one, and agricultural know how, to determine the probable cause for CKDU and use reference to similar occurrence in other countries to further prove his hypothesis.

Simply put where the three factors below all meet, we have kidney disease, and they are, Water from Hill Country Run-off for irrigation, Diet & a Pattern of consistency of this diet over a long period of time, and certain growing conditions of agricultural staples in this case rice, all play a part in this impending disaster, and where these three factors all together/ come together you have the perfect conditions on which CKDU can thrive.

He has studied this subject only for 4 years, and has approached it from the point of view not of Medicine, or Agriculture, but as an Engineer who is able to come down to a common denominator of conditions to explain the prevalence of Kidney Disease in some areas and not  at others.

SO HERE GOES HIS HYPOTHESES

Over decades forest cover has been removed and tea has been grown in the Hills, and fertilizer rich in phosphates have been used over an extended period of time to improve yields. Due to top soil erosion, and waterflows thereon, the rain water, eventually finds its way into the rivers that flow downstream and to the agricultural areas of the Rajarata,

Farmers use enormous amounts of water to grow paddy. He showed a statistic that showed a staggering amount of liters of water to produce one KG of paddy. The cadmium that runs off from these fertilizers, settle on the farmers soil. Water drains down into the soil leaving cadmium deposits far higher than recommended amounts remain in the soil and some times, Arsenic and Lead also collect, making it a triple disaster, leaving completely degraded soil, with a HIGH concentration of these heavy metals.

These farmers then grow paddy in this highly contaminated soil, and within the village, consume the rice they have grown, exclusively, and purchase little or nothing from outside instead of rice as a staple.

Added to this, it is common practice that farmers parboil their home grown rice. When you par boil, not only the cadmium in the grain remains, but also the cadmium deposits in the husk when boiled with the husk prior to milling, will leach any cadmium to the rice itself.

Even though many vegetables grown in similar soil will also contain high concentrations of these same heavy metals, as people only consume much smaller quantities, as compared with the rice they eat, the total cadmium ingested is from eating a lot of rice, compared with limited quantities of other items.

Over time, the increased concentrations of cadmium, which the kidneys clean from the body, will be so much that the kidney just cannot cope with the more than normal amounts of cadmium that average people in the Country consume and clear out of their systems.

With the production of Albumin, in larger quantities, irreversible kidney disease takes place, and medications and dialysis, merely delay the inevitable, BUT DOES NOT reverse the damage as it does not truly address the real causes, in order to eliminate it from one’s diet, before the kidney damage is irreversible.

He quashed the myths about not drinking sufficient amounts of liquid to flush the system when the farmer becomes dehydrated as not being the principal reason for this disease, but which could hasten its speed as the integrity of the kidney is put under pressure as there are not sufficient fluids to flush the out the impurities.

He further emphasized the fact that micro nutrients are also lacking in people’s diets, and this lack can also aid in the speed of the onset of CKDU, but not necessarily be the cause of the disease.

He pointed out that people in urban areas of the Rajarata, are not as badly affected because they have a choice of food intake and don’t usually eat ONLY rice grown by them alone, but would favor no rice based products, diluting the concentration of rice for consumption. That is why a person from Colombo, though including Polonnaruwa rice in his diet will not develop CKDU as he does not simply eat only rice from a particular area. He wanted to say that a varied diet of foods from all over the country will then dilute the regional influence of a particular item of food.

He used the example to say that the water that fills the Senanayake Samudra in Gal Oya does not have run off from the Hills, though it is in the foothills of the Namunukula Range, as there is NO  proportionately large run off from rivers as water merely gets absorbed into the soil and may eventually get into the water table downstream, but that is after filtration and not run off. The Hills off Bibile and Nilgala are not heavily into tea and there is virgin forest that protects the run off, and merely provides the rain water falling there into the Samudra. This is the reason the the Ampara Farmers who use the same fertilizers in similar proportions and have used this for a long time, do not get CKDU and the soil concentration of Cadmium is lower than in the Rajarata.

He also showed graphs and diagrams, to show that in a small area, if people eat rice consistently from land irrigated from rain fed tanks, the incidence of CKDU was less than from Hill Water Run off fed tanks, where the Mahaveli waters are channeled into the Rajarata.

He touched on the Glyphosate issue, as it is a weedicide, and said that studies do not show it results in a high production of Cadmium, and in that sense is NOT as toxic as it is made out to be lately, where there is a ban, but in his opinion will NOT do anything to reduce the catastrophe of CKDU.

He also showed that Nelum Ala contains a high concentration of Cadmium, but as people do not eat it as frequently as rice, it is not of such a high concentration that enters the blood stream, because one does not consume it at similar levels to rice.

He is now conducting an experiment in a small area of Anuradhapura, to prove his hypotheses by getting people in a high affected area to all eat the food that is provided for them by is organization or foundation, and not eat the food they previously ate from what they grew. He could then show that if with the lower concentration of cadmium ingested, any worrying sign of CKDU, could be reversed as the kidneys can now function in the normal way to remove the normal level of heavy metals in acceptable doses as permitted by the WHO.

If one is to IMMEDIATELY address this concern, and not wait any longer for action, until the problem is investigated and solutions found, he suggests that farmers are told NOT to eat the rice they have grown, and for them to have say Australian Rice provided for a few years, just to see if the CKDU threat is reduced, because fewer are actually developing Kidney Disease. This will provide conclusive proof that it is the DIET STUPID.

That will make it easier once the evidence is shown and the jury deliberates, to impose drastic restrictions of a pattern of consumption to reverse the disease.

7 comments:

Ratmale,Minneriya,Sri Lanka said...

In his presentation, Dr Gammanpila intimated that the WHO figures show that there are 400,000 people affected. However he challenged some of the data, saying the curve of protein secretions of CKDU patients show a false positive for a period, where despite failing kidneys, the tests presently carried out do not show deterioration/ or increase in levels of some chemical that is an indicator of failure.

He estimates that there are currently 800,000 affected, and unless quick and immediate action is taken to arrest the diet (which contains a high dose of harmful heavy metals, due to the quantity of the food consumed) that is the main contributory cause to this illness, over a MILLION PEOPLE many at a young age, will die within the next 20 years from this disease, but it can be prevented if steps are taken without delay.

Anonymous said...

With so much resource put into this issue, it is surprising that no one has been able to isolate the reason when the amount of evidence is available and logical people can deduce the probably cause.

This is one deduction, that debunks the water theory, so let the robots decide for a change, maybe artificial intelligence should be used here to come up with a solution

Ratmale,Minneriya,Sri Lanka said...

The Speaker used examples of other deltas, like the Nile Delta in Cairo to say that even there there was a higher incidence due to high concentrations in the soil due to run off and similar deltas in India, Bangladesh were cited as proof of this in an international context.

He further said that with such a number of highly qualified researchers and medical practitioners in this field in Sri Lanka, it is ripe for them to conduct path breaking studies of international repute using the raw material in Sri Lanka, that will be useful for the whole world, and an ideal area for Sri Lanka to shine in the world of research into this deadly disease.

The challenge is made, now lets see if someone/body takes it up, an ideal opportunity to shine

Anonymous said...

Parliament discussed the Glyphosate ban yesterday, 21st March 2018. Rathana Thero, is barking up the wrong tree unfortunately as there is glyphosate use everywhere but CKDU in certain places only. So it is definitely not the main cause, though overuse no doubt of anything could cause health problems in humans exposed.

So he should be concentrating on the main reason people are dying and it does not appear it is not glyphosate per se but contaminated soil in which food is grown, and then the level of intake of consumed food grown in contaminated soil.

All these conditions need to be met, as it is the amount of harmful chemicals NOT in the soil, but in the human body, to the extent that the kidney cannot clean up that is at the heart of the problem, so it is not the water either.

This hypotheses must be tested without delay, in order to come out with recommended diets for people beginning with those in badly affected areas first, before going nationwide.

I am sure that logic is not within the capability of the Rev Rathana Thero as he is simply one track minded, unable to logically think things through to its conclusion

Anonymous said...

Please take time to read some of these articles if possible,

http://panswiss.org/newsroom/glyphosate-linked-to-epidemic-of-kidney-failure-but-regulation-obstructed/
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3945589/
http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2016/03/mysterious-kidney-disease-goes-global
http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/24876-monsantos-herbicide-linked-to-fatal-kidney-disease-epidemic-will-ckdu-topple-monsanto
https://www.globalresearch.ca/monsantos-roundup-herbicide-killing-kidneys-as-well-as-weeds/5425790
http://www.thebubble.com/sickness-nicaraguas-sugar-cane-workers-dying/
https://www.npr.org/sections/health-shots/2014/04/30/306907097/mysterious-kidney-disease-slays-farmworkers-in-central-america
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5442867/

sbarrkum said...

Ranjith

Did Kamal Gammanpila show evidence for levels of Cd in rice grown in different areas.

A properly set up data and Principal component Analysis should identify the most likely culprit.


Ratmale,Minneriya,Sri Lanka said...

Mumbo Jumbo from Jayasumana who opines, but is not rational or logical

Of course Glyphosate is a contributory factor, so is hard water, so what? What is the primary reason that CKDU is in certain areas but not all, though Glyphosate is used in all areas and has over time been a cause of increasing the toxicity of soil when used in abundance.

he should follow the rationale, to weigh the importance of glyphosate as a week killer and other fertilizers like phosphates that are high in cadmium and weigh the pros and cons. I would have expected better from him, but his argument does not wash, or he his poor at delivery.
http://www.dailymirror.lk/article/-Glyphosate-linked-to-kidney-disease-Prof-Channa-Jayasumana-147946.html